I watched both seasons, – and I’m a fan.
It’s rare for something original to be produced today, but this show is exactly that. An absolutely innovative, creative, and novel series, it blends genres to create something utterly unique.
Showrunner Paolo Sorrentino is an interesting storyteller to explore in general, but what he has crafted with the first season of The Young Pope is a true masterpiece. I know, this term is often used inflationarily these days, but in this case, I think it’s fair to apply it.
The Young Pope presents so many ideas I’ve never encountered elsewhere that I wish it lasted at least for five seasons and a movie. Sadly, there are only 10 episodes, and a somewhat less intriguing second season titled The New Pope.
Jude Law plays the pope in this show, and you can never be sure if he is the good guy, the bad guy, or not even a guy at all. The show constantly shifts between drama, comedy, and surreal art. Is it making fun of religion? Whenever you’re close to saying yes, it offers you a scene that actually celebrates Christianity. Is it blasphemous? Whenever you feel that it is, it presents a scene that honors faith.
It’s a slow-paced show that takes its time. There aren’t big explosions or car chases. It’s certainly not a Game of Thrones-style backstabbing story set in the Vatican either. The only label I can give this show is the one I’ve used from the start: The Young Pope is utterly unique. Watch it if that sounds interesting to you.